I performed some bidding magic at Cigar Auctioneer for two months to start this year.  While not equal to Cigar Bid as far as price goes, they do have enough good blends offered up at decent prices that it would be smarter  to try and win what you want as opposed to an outright purchase.  A few very good cigars I discovered their during my short bidding run were the.....

CAPOEIRA MADURO TORO (6" x 50) Rated '90'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
CONUCO DOUBLE TORO (6" x 60) Rated '83'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
DON TOMAS SPECIAL EDITION CONNECTICUT TORO (6" x 52) Rated '88'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
FAMOUS NICARAGUAN 3000 DOUBLE TORO (6"x 60) Rated '83'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
FAMOUS NICARAGUAN 6000 CHURCHILL (7" x 50) Rated '82'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
FINAL BLEND ROBUSTO (5" x 50) Rated '86'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
FONSECA SERIE 'F' ROBUSTO (5" x 52) Rated 85
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
LA FLORIDITA LIMITED EDITION MAGNUM (5" x 60) Rated '90'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
PERDOMO ALABAO ROBUSTO (5" x 54) Rated '88'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
ROCKY PATEL CUBAN BLEND TORO (6" x 52) Rated '90'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
ROCKY PATEL CUBAN BLEND MADURO TORO (6" x 52) Rated '90'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
SAINT LUIS REY SERIE 'G' BELICOSO (6.5" x 54) Rated '88'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
SAINT LUIS REY SERIE 'G' MADURO BELICOSO (6.5" x 54) Rated '90'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
SIGNATURE SERIES ROBUSTO by Don Pepin Garcia (5" x 50) Rated '88'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
TABACOS BAEZ SERIE 'SF' TORO (6" x 50) Rated '87'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
VEGAFINA ROBUSTO (5" x 52) Rated '85'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
XEN TORPEDO by Nish Patel (6" x 52) Rated '93' 
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand
VUDU MADURO CHURCHILL (7" x 50) Rated '82'
http://www.cigarauctioneer.com/search.cfm/st/aucbrand